Citizen Advisory Action Board

Board Description
Board Composition:The San Antonio Police Department is asking for any residents interested in serving the community to apply for the Chief’s Advisory Action Board (CAAB). As part of the Police Executive Research Forum study, the group recommended a change in the composition and appointment of the board. This change would result in a balance between the rights of the accused officers and the interests of the community the department is meant to protect. As a result, the San Antonio Police Officers Association and the San Antonio Police Department agreed in the Collective Bargaining Agreement that the board will be comprised of 7 appointees selected from a panel of fourteen (14) members. Seven uniformed employees will also serve on the Board. The Collective Bargaining Agreement was passed by Mayor and City Council in September 2016. There will be opportunities to rotate citizens on the Board. Members of the board of the Advisory Action Board will be required to attend the Chief’s Advisory Action Board (CAAB) meetings in the conference room located within the Internal Affairs Office. Meeting frequency is dependent on the caseload but could occur bi-weekly. Additionally, they will be required to prepare for the meetings by reviewing the cases that will be discussed and voted on during the course of the meetings. During the board meetings, the members will hear a detailed briefing of the various cases that are on the agenda by their respective investigator and will also have the opportunity to question the complainants as well as the accused officers, if the complainants and/or officers choose to attend the meetings. The board members will then be given the opportunity to cast a secret ballot on how the case should be disposed of. If the case is sustained by a majority, the members will have a second vote to determine a recommended discipline. Members should be aware that their decisions are only recommendations, and the final decision on the various cases under investigation will be made by the Chief of Police.
Appointed by:City Council
District; At-Large; Mayoral Appointment:Other
Categories:The Complaint and Administrative Review Board (CARB) is made up of two independent boards (Sworn and Civilian). The Sworn Board has seven members comprised of the following ranks: Deputy Chief, Captain, Lieutenant, Sergeant, Detective, and two Officers. The Civilian Board has seven members from the community who are approved by City Council. The Deputy Chief serves as the Board Chairperson. The CARB rotates members every six months.
Mission/Purpose:The Complaint and Administrative Review Board (CARB) reviews cases of alleged non-criminal misconduct committed by police officers. After reviewing the cases the Complaint and Administrative Review Board members make recommendations to the Chief of Police as to whether discipline is warranted.
Meeting Schedule & Location:Meetings are held twice monthly on Wednesday's at 8:30 a.m. in the Internal Affairs Conference room, 800 Dolorosa.
Website Information:For additional information, please contact:
Ordinance/Articles of Incorporation/By Laws:2010-12-16-1090

Liaison: Joefrank Picazo - (210) 207-7360

NameDistrictAppointed DateDate Expires
Mr. Jeremiah K. Broderick Other02/20/202005/05/2024
Mr. Paul Andrew Drummond Other05/05/202205/05/2024
Mrs. Karen Farias Other02/20/202005/05/2024
Mr. Jay Franklin Other05/05/202205/05/2024
Mr. Vincent Bernard Holman Sr.Other05/05/202205/05/2024
Ms. Nadia Islam Other12/17/202012/02/2022
Ms. Sydney Knowles Other10/14/202110/14/2023
Mr. Roy Edward Lozano JrOther02/20/202005/05/2024
Mr Juan Carlos Merlo Other10/14/202110/14/2023
Ms. Lillian Rivera Other05/05/202205/05/2024
Ms Cristina Villegas-Hernandez Other12/17/202012/02/2022
Ms Deborah Warner Other05/05/202205/05/2024
Ms Tammy Lyn Wincott Other10/14/202110/14/2023
Mrs. Raquel Zapata Other06/20/201910/14/2023

Total Members for Citizen Advisory Action Board: 14 City of San Antonio - Agenda Details Printable Version